Skip to content
All free planners

Which roof bid costs less for the same work?

One roofer includes tear-off and hauling. Another lists them as extras. Put both bids on the same footing before you compare the totals.

Free worksheet and checklist. No email required.
30-second planner walkthrough
Open the walkthrough video (MP4)

Choose your goal and use its checklist to gather the figures for your worksheet.

Choose one scope for both bids. Add the quoted price of required work each bid leaves out. Enter zero for confirmed inclusions and get a price for unknowns. Sample figures illustrate two bids.

Ask both roofers to put the matched scope, exclusions and price for any additional decking in writing. Keep the warranty terms with each bid.

Step 1 of 3

Choose your goal

Goal checklist

I'm pricing a roof repair

Check off each question when you have an answer.

Goal checklist

I'm replacing my roof

Check off each question when you have an answer.

Goal checklist

I manage an occupied property

Check off each question when you have an answer.

Step 2 of 3

Two-bid roof comparison

Choose one scope for both bids. Add the quoted price of required work each bid leaves out. Enter zero for confirmed inclusions and get a price for unknowns. Sample figures illustrate two bids.

USD
USD
For example, a separate haul-away quote.
USD
USD
Use the same assumptions about repairs and quantities as for bid A.

Your estimate

Enter a number in each field to see your estimate. You can change any figure to see how it affects the result.

Can someone beat my quote?
Step 3 of 3

Take your checklist with you

Ask both roofers to put the matched scope, exclusions and price for any additional decking in writing. Keep the warranty terms with each bid.

Reference · National Roofing Contractors Association guide to selecting a contractor

Free price comparison

Can someone beat my quote?

Start with the price you were actually quoted. See what another written quote or your own target would change. No contact details required.

Prices to compare
USD

Your starting point

Enter your current quote to see the price a comparable quote would need to beat.

Check the scope

  • Match the roof area, shingle or membrane and underlayment.
  • Check tear-off, disposal, permits and the price of additional decking.
  • Compare the written labor and material warranties.